Monday, November 29, 2010

Media Heroes #1 and Salon’s Media Hacks Viewers Votes Maddow #1 Hero

Tags: The Nation and Salon Media Heroes and Hacks

You may note that does not know how to spell the name of some liberals their readers called media hacks. Even though these polls are not necessarily universally accurate, they are fun to read, especially if you have your favorite heroes and hacks. Rachel Maddow picked #1 hero! Hacks include

Jim Kawakami, Nov 29, 2010,

Results of '30 Media Heroes' Voting Announced: Maddow Takes Top Spot!

Greg Mitchell

November 29, 2010 We've been having fun since Wednesday with a response to Salon's popular "30 Biggest Media Hacks" list, sponsoring a readers' ballot to pick "30 Media Heroes." The response was overwhelming, with over 1,200 votes pouring in via Comments at the end of the original story, via e-mail to me directly and at Twitter (via @GregMitch). Votes obviously came from regular Nation readers, but also from many others.

Related Content

Jon Stewart's 'War Criminal' Past, Presidents and Future

Stewart v. Maddow: The Thrilla Was Vanilla

Olbermann's Suspension Was the Worst Person(nel Decision) in the World

Maddow Hits GOP's 'Southern Strategy'—But Who Was That Enabler She Quoted?

The Face of an American Lost Generation

About the Author


Greg Mitchell

Greg Mitchell writes the Media Fix blog for A new edition of his book The Campaign of the Century: Upton...

Also by The Author

[ Click for More ]

DAYBOOK for Monday: Special Edition—Live-blogging WikiLeaks, Day 2 (Media)

Greg Mitchell

pastedGraphic_1.pdf 7 comments

Blogging the WikiLeaks Release: Day 1

Greg Mitchell

pastedGraphic_2.pdf 10 comments

Related Topics

Amy Goodman Matt Taibbi Rachel Maddow

Now we're ready to announce the winners. But first a "trend" comment: Clearly, print got little respect in this vote, with a vast majority of top spots going to TV hosts, or very popular bloggers (who also appear on the tube a fair amount). Practically all of the MSNBC line-up, except Chris Matthews, made the Top 30 or Very Honorable Mention. Also: Jon Stewart rather comfortably topped stablemate Stephen Colbert.


Now, the drum roll please and.... congrats to Rachel Maddow, who rather easily earned the top spot in this balloting. She led from starting gate to the wire. In a close race, Amy Goodman beat out Glenn Greenwald and Matt Taibbi for the #2 slot. The venerable Bill Moyers finished fifth. Julian Assange made a late move to crack the top 30, although he also drew many critics.

See the full list below. The vote for those past the top 16 was extremely close, they could almost be placed in any order. What's most heartening: so many truly valuable people did not make the Top 30 or the Honorables list.

Also, I'd like to thank the fairly large number of people who voted for yours truly, but I decided to take myself out of the running, for obvious reasons. Feel free to erect an statue, if you'd like.

Here we go:

1. Rachel Maddow (MSNBC)

2. Amy Goodman (Democracy Now!)

3. Glenn Greenwald (Salon)

4. Matt Taibbi (Rolling Stone and more)

5. Bill Moyers (formerly PBS)

6. Jon Stewart (The Daily Show)

7. Keith Olbermann (MSNBC)

8. Jeremy Scahill (The Nation)

9. Paul Krugman (New York Times)

10. Stephen Colbert (Colbert Report)

11. Chris Hayes (The Nation, MSNBC)

12. Seymour Hersh (The New Yorker and more)

13. Chris Hedges (The Nation and more)

14. Arianna Huffington (Huffington Post)

15. Jane Hamsher (FireDogLake)

16. Cenk Uygur (The Young Turks)

17. Naomi Klein (The Nation)

18. Dylan Rattigan (MSNBC)

19. Bill Maher (HBO)

20. Frank Rich (New York Times)

21. David Sirota (syndicated columnist)

22. Thom Hartmann (radio)

23. Julian Assange (WikiLeaks)

24. Digby -- i.e. Heather Parton (blogger)

25. Greg Palast (writer)

26. Ed Schultz (MSNBC)

27. Laura Flanders (GRIT TV and more)

28. Allison Kilkenny-Jamie Kilstein (Citizen Radio team)

29. Sam Seder (Huffington Post and Majority Report)

30. Jim Hightower (The Nation and more) Top 30 Media Hacks: VERY HONORABLE MENTIONS: Markos Moulistas, Lawrence O'Donnell, Katrina vandenHeuvel, Eric Boehlert, Bob Herbert, Josh Marshall, Marcy Wheeler, Robert Scheer, Helen Thomas, Dean Baker, Yves Smith, Nick Kristof, Ezra Klein, Atrios, Mike Malloy, Max Blumenthal, Joe Conason. More: Robert Fisk, Melissa Harris-Perry, David Swanson, Nate Silver, Ali Abuniman, Gail Collins, Dave Wegiel, Eugene Robinson.

Greg Mitchell

You'll find some of your least favorites there, from Marty Peretz and Jonah Goldberg to, at the very top, Richard Cohen and Mark Halperin. The Washington Post grabs eight slots and the New York Times contributes David Brooks and even those alleged liberals Maureen Dowd and Thomas Friedman.

Anyway, for much-needed balance, and to remain positive (for a rare time?), allow me to propose that you, dear readers, vote for a 30 Biggest Heroes of the media, using the Comments section below, or e-mailing me at, or filing via Twitter @GregMitch. Of course, you can and should include bloggers and social (network) misfits, plus TV hosts and satirists and pundits, and even print legends!

No comments:

Post a Comment